Most NDIS and aged care providers build their rosters around casual staff because support needs change week to week. But flexibility now comes with a compliance question that didn’t exist in quite the same form before August 2024. If a casual support worker has been rostered onto the same regular shifts for months, do they still count as casual, or have they earned the right to ask for something more permanent?
Casual conversion is the legal process that lets an eligible casual employee request a move to full-time or part-time employment, and it now runs through a new “employee choice” pathway under the Fair Work Act. For providers who run large casual workforces across disability and aged care services, understanding how this pathway works, where the SCHADS Award fits in, and what a recent Fair Work Commission ruling means for rostering decisions is no longer optional reading. It’s part of running a compliant workforce.
What Is Casual Conversion?
Casual conversion is the right of an eligible casual employee to ask their employer, in writing, to change their employment to full-time or part-time (permanent) status, triggering a formal response process with set timeframes and limited grounds for refusal. It replaced the old conversion rules on 26 August 2024, when the Fair Work Act’s “employee choice pathway” came into effect as part of the Closing Loopholes amendments.
Under the current rules, a worker stays casual until one of three things happens: they accept an offer of permanent employment and start on that basis, they convert under the National Employment Standards, an award, or an enterprise agreement, or the Fair Work Commission orders the change. Simply calling someone “casual” in their contract, or paying them a casual loading, doesn’t settle the question on its own. What actually matters is the real pattern of the work.
Why This Matters More in Disability and Aged Care Than in Most Industries
Casual conversion isn’t an abstract legal topic here; it’s a workforce planning problem hiding in plain sight. According to the National Disability Services (NDS) Workforce Census, roughly 37 to 39 percent of the disability support workforce is employed on a casual basis, well above most other industries. The same research found casual disability support workers leave their jobs at a 24 percent annual rate, against 16 percent for permanent staff, a gap that costs providers heavily in recruitment and lost continuity of care.
That combination means casual conversion sits right at the intersection of two things providers already care about: wage compliance and keeping good support workers. A provider that treats casual conversion purely as a legal box to tick, rather than a retention lever, is missing half the picture.
How the Employee Choice Pathway Actually Works

The employee choice pathway gives eligible casuals a direct route to request casual conversion to permanent employment, and it runs on fairly tight timeframes.
Eligibility. A casual employee needs at least 6 months of service with the business (12 months if the employer is a small business), and they need to genuinely believe they no longer meet the definition of a casual employee. Service before 26 August 2024 doesn’t count toward that period. Casuals who were already employed before that date were able to start using the new pathway from 26 February 2025 (26 August 2025 for small business employees).
The notice. The employee gives written notice that they want to move to full-time or part-time employment. They can’t do this during an unresolved dispute, or within 6 months of a previous notice being refused.
The employer’s response. This is the part rostering teams need to watch closely. The employer must consult the employee, then respond in writing within 21 days. Missing that window is a breach of the National Employment Standards, not a minor administrative slip.
| Step | Requirement | Timeframe |
|---|---|---|
| Employee eligibility | 6 months’ service (12 months, small business) | From 26 August 2024, or transitional dates below |
| Transitional access for existing casuals | Can use the pathway | From 26 February 2025 (26 August 2025, small business) |
| Employee notice | Written notice to employer | Any time once eligible, subject to restrictions |
| Employer consultation and response | Written response, accept or refuse with reasons | Within 21 days of notice |
| Effective date (if accepted) | New hours and status apply | First full pay period after the response, unless agreed otherwise |
| Disputes | Fair Work Commission mediation, conciliation, then arbitration if unresolved | Ongoing until resolved |
Accepting the request. A response accepting the change must state the employee’s new status, their new hours, and the start date, usually the first full pay period after the response is given.
Refusing the request. An employer can only refuse on specific grounds: the employee still genuinely meets the casual definition, there are fair and reasonable operational grounds (a substantial change to how work is organised, a significant business impact, or changes needed to comply with an award), or accepting would breach a legally required recruitment process. Cost alone isn’t a valid reason.
Unresolved disputes go to the Fair Work Commission, which tries informal resolution first and can arbitrate a binding outcome if that fails.
The SCHADS Award and Casual Conversion: What’s Different, and What Isn’t
The Social, Community, Home Care and Disability Services Industry Award (SCHADS, or MA000100) doesn’t run its own separate casual conversion scheme anymore. Like most modern awards, it now defers to the National Employment Standards and the employee choice pathway described above. What the SCHADS Award does set independently is the casual loading itself: 25 percent on top of the base hourly rate, for ordinary hours.
That loading is meant to compensate casuals for the entitlements they miss out on, such as paid leave and notice of termination. It’s not a reason to delay or refuse a casual conversion request. In fact, the Fair Work Commission has specifically noted that because casuals already receive a loaded rate, an employer will struggle to justify refusing casual conversion purely on cost grounds.
For providers juggling SCHADS Award classifications and penalty rates across a mixed casual and permanent roster, the practical challenge isn’t understanding the award rate; it’s knowing which casual support workers have quietly built up a regular enough pattern of work to be eligible for casual conversion.
What the First Fair Work Commission Ruling Means for Your Roster
The employee choice pathway had its first real test recently, when the Fair Work Commission ordered a university to convert a long-serving casual academic to part-time employment. The case is worth paying attention to well beyond higher education, because the Commission’s reasoning goes directly to how rosters get built in disability and aged care.
The worker’s contract described him as casual, with no guaranteed hours. But in practice, he’d taught the same subject across consecutive semesters on a regular timetable, a pattern the Commission said looked “more akin to recurring fixed-term periods of part-time employment” than genuine casual work. The contract’s label didn’t match the substance of the arrangement, and substance won.
Translate that into a support work context: a casual rostered onto the same client, the same shifts, week after week, for six months or more, starts to look a lot like an employee with an advance commitment to ongoing work, whatever the roster software calls them. Providers who build continuity of care through the same familiar casual support worker, often genuinely good for the participant or resident, are also the providers most exposed to a casual conversion claim if they haven’t planned for it.
How to Assess Whether a Casual Should Convert
There’s no single factor that decides whether someone is really still casual. The Fair Work Act points to the real substance of the relationship, looking at things like:
- Whether shifts are regularly offered and regularly accepted, rather than genuinely variable
- Whether future work with this person is reasonably likely to continue
- Whether a permanent part-time or full-time worker does the same kind of work
- Whether a firm, advance commitment to continuing work exists in practice, even if it’s never written down
A regular pattern on its own doesn’t automatically entitle a casual to convert, but it’s the factor rostering teams are best placed to track for casual conversion purposes, because it lives in the roster data itself.
Grounds a Provider Can (and Can’t) Rely On to Refuse
It’s worth being explicit about what counts as a legitimate refusal, because getting this wrong is where disputes start.
Valid grounds include the employee genuinely still meeting the casual definition, a substantial operational change that makes the new arrangement unworkable, a significant adverse impact on the business that can be demonstrated, or a legal recruitment process (such as a merit-based selection requirement) that conversion would bypass.
What doesn’t hold up: a blanket preference for casual flexibility, concern about the cost of leave entitlements, or simply not wanting to set a precedent. None of these are accepted grounds, and a casual conversion refusal built on them is likely to fail if it reaches the Commission.
Managing Casual Conversion Risk Through Smarter Rostering, Not Guesswork

The practical difficulty for most providers isn’t the law itself; it’s visibility. When casual shifts are tracked across spreadsheets or several disconnected systems, nobody notices that a support worker has quietly crossed the 6-month threshold with a near-identical weekly pattern until a casual conversion request lands on a manager’s desk with a 21-day clock already running.
This is exactly where VisiCase’s rostering and workforce management platform earns its place. Because every shift, every client assignment, and every SCHADS Award classification sits in one system, providers can see at a glance which casual support workers are building up the kind of regular pattern that matters under the employee choice pathway, well before the 21-day response window opens. The features built into VisiCase include automated award interpretation, so pay rates and allowances stay correct regardless of whether a worker eventually converts, and smarter scheduling tools that flag rostering patterns worth a second look rather than leaving them buried in historical data.
Getting ahead of casual conversion requests also pays off on the retention side. Providers who proactively offer permanent part-time roles to their most reliable casual support workers, rather than waiting for a formal notice, often come out ahead. Our piece on reducing support worker turnover covers this from the retention angle in more depth.
A Practical Compliance Checklist for NDIS and Aged Care Providers
- Issue the Casual Employment Information Statement before, or as soon as possible after, a casual starts, then again at 6 and 12 months and every 12 months after.
- Track roster patterns, not just hours worked, so casuals approaching the 6-month eligibility mark are identified early.
- Calendar the 21-day response window the moment a written casual conversion notice arrives, leaving time for genuine consultation first.
- Document the reasoning behind any accept or refuse decision, tying it to a recognised ground, not a general business preference.
- Review SCHADS Award classifications and casual loading alongside conversion decisions, so pay stays aligned with the new employment status.
- Train rostering and HR staff on the current employee choice pathway, since outdated guidance about the old rules is still circulating in the sector.
- Escalate disputes early through the Fair Work Commission’s informal resolution process rather than letting disagreements sit unresolved.
Getting Casual Conversion Right Is a Workforce Strategy, Not Just a Compliance Task
Casual conversion will keep producing test cases as more workers use the employee choice pathway, and disability and aged care providers, with their unusually high reliance on casual staff, are squarely in the firing line. The providers who come out ahead won’t be the ones who refuse every request by default; they’ll be the ones who already know, from their own roster data, which casual support workers have built up a genuine pattern of ongoing work and have planned for it accordingly.
If your rostering system can’t tell you that today, it’s worth finding out before a 21-day clock starts running on a casual conversion request you didn’t see coming. Get in touch with the VisiCase team to see how automated rostering and award compliance can take the guesswork out of casual conversion.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is casual conversion?
Casual conversion is the process that lets an eligible casual employee ask their employer, in writing, to change their employment to full-time or part-time status. Since August 2024, this runs through the Fair Work Actu2019s employee choice pathway, which sets out who can ask, how, and on what grounds an employer can say no.
Who is eligible to request casual conversion under the employee choice pathway?
A casual employee becomes eligible once theyu2019ve worked for the business for at least 6 months, or 12 months if the employer is a small business, and genuinely believe they no longer meet the definition of a casual employee. Time worked before 26 August 2024 doesnu2019t count toward that period, which is why many long-serving casuals only became eligible in 2025.
How long does an NDIS or aged care provider have to respond to a casual conversion request?
Employers must consult the employee and respond in writing within 21 days of receiving the notice. The response has to either accept the change, stating the new status, hours, and start date, or refuse it with reasons that fit one of the recognised grounds under the Fair Work Act.
Can a provider refuse a casual conversion request?
Yes, but only on specific grounds: the employee still genuinely meets the casual employee definition, there are fair and reasonable operational grounds such as a major change to how work is organised, or accepting would breach a legally required recruitment process. A general preference for flexibility or concern about leave costs isnu2019t a valid reason and is unlikely to hold up if the matter goes to the Fair Work Commission.
Does the SCHADS Award have its own casual conversion clause?
No, the SCHADS Award no longer runs a separate conversion process of its own. Like most modern awards, it defers to the National Employment Standards and the employee choice pathway. What SCHADS does set independently is the casual loading, paid at 25 percent above the base hourly rate for ordinary hours.
What is the casual loading under the SCHADS Award?
The casual loading under the SCHADS Award is 25 percent on top of the relevant base hourly rate for ordinary hours. Itu2019s designed to compensate casual employees for entitlements they donu2019t receive, such as paid leave, and it continues regardless of whether a worker later converts to permanent employment.
What happens if a casual conversion dispute can’t be resolved between the employer and employee?
Unresolved disputes go to the Fair Work Commission, which first tries informal methods such as mediation or conciliation. If that doesnu2019t settle the matter, the Commission can arbitrate and make a binding decision, which may include ordering the employer to convert the employee.
How does a regular roster pattern affect whether a support worker is genuinely casual?
A regular pattern of shifts doesnu2019t automatically make someone permanent, but itu2019s one of several factors the Fair Work Commission weighs when deciding whether a genuine advance commitment to ongoing work exists. A recent Commission ruling found that a worker rostered onto the same recurring pattern, despite a casual contract, was effectively working as a part-time employee in substance, not just in name.
When did the current casual employment and conversion rules take effect?
The new casual employee definition and the employee choice pathway both took effect on 26 August 2024, as part of the Fair Work Actu2019s Closing Loopholes amendments. Casuals employed before that date gained access to the new pathway from 26 February 2025, or 26 August 2025 for small business employees.
How can rostering software help NDIS and aged care providers manage casual conversion risk?
Purpose-built rostering software can flag casual support workers whose shift patterns are approaching the eligibility thresholds for casual conversion, well before a written notice arrives and starts the 21-day response clock. Platforms like VisiCase combine rostering, SCHADS Award interpretation, and workforce data in one place, so providers can plan for conversion proactively instead of reacting under time pressure.
Casual conversion is the process that lets an eligible casual employee ask their employer, in writing, to change their employment to full-time or part-time status. Since August 2024, this runs through the Fair Work Act’s employee choice pathway, which sets out who can ask, how, and on what grounds an employer can say no.
A casual employee becomes eligible once they’ve worked for the business for at least 6 months, or 12 months if the employer is a small business, and genuinely believe they no longer meet the definition of a casual employee. Time worked before 26 August 2024 doesn’t count toward that period, which is why many long-serving casuals only became eligible in 2025.
Employers must consult the employee and respond in writing within 21 days of receiving the notice. The response has to either accept the change, stating the new status, hours, and start date, or refuse it with reasons that fit one of the recognised grounds under the Fair Work Act.
Yes, but only on specific grounds: the employee still genuinely meets the casual employee definition, there are fair and reasonable operational grounds such as a major change to how work is organised, or accepting would breach a legally required recruitment process. A general preference for flexibility or concern about leave costs isn’t a valid reason and is unlikely to hold up if the matter goes to the Fair Work Commission.
No, the SCHADS Award no longer runs a separate conversion process of its own. Like most modern awards, it defers to the National Employment Standards and the employee choice pathway. What SCHADS does set independently is the casual loading, paid at 25 percent above the base hourly rate for ordinary hours.
The casual loading under the SCHADS Award is 25 percent on top of the relevant base hourly rate for ordinary hours. It’s designed to compensate casual employees for entitlements they don’t receive, such as paid leave, and it continues regardless of whether a worker later converts to permanent employment.
Unresolved disputes go to the Fair Work Commission, which first tries informal methods such as mediation or conciliation. If that doesn’t settle the matter, the Commission can arbitrate and make a binding decision, which may include ordering the employer to convert the employee.
A regular pattern of shifts doesn’t automatically make someone permanent, but it’s one of several factors the Fair Work Commission weighs when deciding whether a genuine advance commitment to ongoing work exists. A recent Commission ruling found that a worker rostered onto the same recurring pattern, despite a casual contract, was effectively working as a part-time employee in substance, not just in name.
The new casual employee definition and the employee choice pathway both took effect on 26 August 2024, as part of the Fair Work Act’s Closing Loopholes amendments. Casuals employed before that date gained access to the new pathway from 26 February 2025, or 26 August 2025 for small business employees.
Purpose-built rostering software can flag casual support workers whose shift patterns are approaching the eligibility thresholds for casual conversion, well before a written notice arrives and starts the 21-day response clock. Platforms like VisiCase combine rostering, SCHADS Award interpretation, and workforce data in one place, so providers can plan for conversion proactively instead of reacting under time pressure.






